• A
  • A
  • Competitie rond collegegeld

    - Collegegelden gaan meer en meer een concurrentiethema worden. Britten, Zweden én Nederlanders denken hier al sterk over na en voeren nu ook beleid. “It is not reasonable to expect Swedish taxpayers to sponsor foreign students’ studies,” zegt HO-minister Tobias Krantz in Stockholm bijvoorbeeld. En Camilla, hertogin van Cornwall, moet nog bij komen van de schrik.

    Overseas students are a lucrative source of income for universities all over Europe. Currently, the UK is the undisputed champion: the alma mater to 214,000 non-EU international students. The OECD expects this number to grow to 258,000 by 2015 so that 10% of undergraduate and 50% of postgraduate students in the UK will be from overseas. However, recent developments might work against these predictions as British Prime Minister, David Cameron, lives up to his campaign promises of slashing budget deficits and immigration numbers.

    From caps to fees

    Home Secretary Theresa May recently explained British MPs that Great Britain had to "take action across all routes to entry - work visas, student visas, family visas". The new government's goal is to cut immigration numbers of currently 196,000 per year to the "tens of thousands" by 2015. The catch: this immigration cap would also entail refusing visas to up to 88,000 overseas students.

    Those foreign students who do make it across the border may then join their fellow British students paying higher tuition fees to decrease UK's debt burden. UK and EU students currently face annual fees of £3,000 per year (around € 3,500), overseas students are charged between £6,250 and £18,000.

    Living up to his second campaign promise, Prime Minister Cameron introduced legislation that would double or triple tuition fees for both UK/EU and overseas students. The necessary legislation squeezed through the House of Commons last week, deeply dividing the LibDem coalition partner of Cameron's Tories. Nobody was more in shock about this than Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall in her Bentley.

    Scandinavian taxpayers worried

    Shifting higher burdens to students is not only favored in the UK, but seems prominent in other countries as well. Sweden is often seen as leading in innovative education policies. There, it was common sense that all Swedish, EU and overseas students could study for free. This generous system was questioned once debt levels rose all over Europe. That is why from 2011 on all of the currently 10,000 non-EU students will be charged up 200,000 kronor (over € 21,000) while Swedish and EU students go on studying for free.

    "It is not reasonable to expect Swedish taxpayers to sponsor foreign students' studies," states Tobias Krantz, Minister for Higher Education and Research. "Swedish students who wish to study abroad have to pay." Charging foreign students more than home/EU students is seen by many EU governments as a reasonable measure to protect taxpayers. It is interesting to note, however, which countries now move towards a system that is more restrictive for foreign students and those that are not.

    Dutch treat

    Prof. Philip Eijlander, Dean of the University of Tilburg, recently prodded Dutch universities to take advantage of this trend. Speaking at the seminar on Jo Ritzens latest book on the position of universities in Europe he pointed out: "We can gain a competitive edge out of this situation. The Dutch tuition fees are still quite reasonable and will now become much more competitive, even for students who would prefer to go to British HE-institutions. Here in the Netherlands they can receive well regarded degrees in English language subjects and studies. The top-universities in Britain will try to be able to 'catch' the very best students from abroad in any way, probably by extra scholarships etc .

    But Dutch universities will be able to attract many more of the candidates for the English language institutions as long as we will be effective in presenting the quality we can offer them. The most recent CHE-ranking is just one example of the very good quality-assessment our whole HE-system receives, not just individual universities, as is still the case with almost all other HE in other European countries and outside Europe."